A paper in dispute (2,5)
I believe the answer is:
at issue
'in dispute' is the definition.
('at issue' can be a synonym of 'in dispute')
'a paper' is the wordplay.
'paper' becomes 'tissue' (tissue is a kind of paper).
'a'+'tissue'='AT ISSUE'
(Other definitions for at issue that I've seen before include "under debate" , "in dispute" , "In question, under discussion" , "Being discussed or disputed" , "Questionable" .)