Cryptic (9)
'cryptic' is the definition.
(both mean puzzling)
This is the entire clue.
(Other definitions for enigmatic that I've seen before include "Like a puzzle" , "with a mystery ingredient" , "Difficult to interpret" , "Cryptic, mysterious" , "Mystifying" .)
(Other definitions for baffling that I've seen before include "Hard to understand" , "Confusing, puzzling" , "Perplexing, puzzling" , "Mystifying" , "Mysterious" .)