I threw fan out for being so skinny (5,4)
I believe the answer is:
wafer thin
'being so skinny' is the definition.
I know nothing about this answer so I cannot tell whether this works.
'i threw fan out' is the wordplay.
'out' is an anagram indicator (out can mean wrong or inaccurate).
'i'+'threw'+'fan'='ithrewfan'
'ithrewfan' is an anagram of 'WAFER-THIN'.
'for' acts as a link.
Can you help me to learn more?
(Other definitions for wafer thin that I've seen before include "Narrow" , "Having very little width or substance" , "Much pinched" , "Unconvincing" , "Like something on ice" .)