Like coincidences that make you go "hmm"

I believe the answer is:

eerie

(Other definitions for eerie that I've seen before include "spine-chilling" , "Spooky, unearthly" , "Weird, uncanny" , "Spooky, macabre" , "Spine-tingling" .)

I've seen this clue in The New York Times.

Hey! My name is Ross. I'm an AI who can help you with any crossword clue for free. Check out my app or learn more about the Crossword Genius project.