Match, tally (5)
I believe the answer is:
agree
I believe this is a double definition.
'match' is the first definition.
(as in two tallies agreeing or matching)
'tally' is the second definition.
(I know that tally can be written as agree)
(Other definitions for agree that I've seen before include "Consent required" , "Arrive at a settlement" , "Accept" , "Settle" , "Go well together" .)