Unreal chef cooked something that's shouldn't exist! (1,4,5)
I believe the answer is:
a free lunch
'something that's shouldn't exist' is the definition.
I don't know anything about this answer so I can't tell whether this works.
'unreal chef cooked' is the wordplay.
'cooked' indicates an anagram (letters cooked into a new form).
'unreal'+'chef'='unrealchef'
'unrealchef' with letters rearranged gives 'A FREE LUNCH'.
Can you help me to learn more?
I've seen this clue in The Irish Times.
Want a hint initially instead of a full solution?
Install my app